Mom refuses to give out son's savings account information after grandmother demands the details so she can make a deposit: 'Just give me cash'

Advertisement
  • Woman in a dress holding a Piggy Bank
  • AITAH for refusing to give out my son's saving account information?

    A couple years ago I set up a special savings account for my son. Monthly we deposit $25 into it as well as a small chunk of our tax return money every year, we hope to increase the amount one day but for now this is what we can afford.
  • On top of that, anytime family gives us money for his savings I immediately transfer money from our bank account into my son's savings.
  • Currently I am the only one who has access to it, because my husband wasn't able to make it to the bank the day I set it up because he was called into work on his day off, which s ks but it is what it is for now.
  • I don't hide the account information from my husband and he knows how much is in it and he can see the monthly withdrawals from our joint account into the savings account and he can ask at any time to see the account from my bank app.
  • He is the only person I ever want to have access to it until our son is older.
  • The problem is my MIL has decided she wants to deposit money into his account monthly, I told her to either give me cash or deposit it into our joint account and I will transfer it but she wants my son's savings account information.
  • I told her very simply that I would not be giving out my son's account information to anyone and that the two options I gave her were the only options she had.
  • She was definitely not happy by that but I do not care because I refuse to give out my son's private information.
  • This was back in December and we haven't seen her since because we've been sick a lot, but she usually texts me every so often and she hasn't reached out to me since the last visit which is very unusual for her.
  • I wonder if she is really that upset and if IATAH for refusing to give her that information.
  • Tl;dr MIL wants access to son's savings account to make monthly deposits but I wont give her access, will let her deposit into our joint account or give us cash for me to transfer but she is upset she can't get access.
  • Boy in Gray Long Sleeve Shirt Putting Coins in a Piggy Bank
  • Equivalent Lemon_319 "but she wants my son's savings account information" Like, just the account # to transfer or the login information? There's a difference
  • moonmanbaby90272 Original Poster's Reply I didn't clarify what she was referring to, I assume it was the account and routing numbers to make a transfer but it's not something I would give out anyways. Multiple family members know we have the account, that's why many of them give us cash for his birthday or Christmas and they know I just transfer money directly into his savings.
  • Equivalent Lemon_319 Tbh I think you at least should have, or came at it more calmly, because jumping straight to "I REFUSE TO GIVE OUT MY SON'S PRIVATE INFORMATION" sends a message to her that you think she'd do something nefarious, which I think she is right to be upset by when all she wanted to do was deposit money towards his future. Either way you're the parent so it's up to you, but you probably gave her more attitude than what was necessary.
  • moonmanbaby90272 Original Poster's Reply Tbh I can see that but I have had a lot of issues with her disregarding boundaries and simple requests that when she made it clear she wanted the information I put my foot down quickly to avoid it going any further. She is nice to an extent but she has a ugly side to her that I always feel like I have to try and play nice with but when it comes to protecting my son I refuse to play nice. I feel that if her intentions were truly to help him than she would
  • Stellar_Jay8 It's a pretty normal ask for routing and account numbers so she can wire money. She wouldn't be able to see details or remove any...
  • facinationstreet If you only share the account # information, she will ONLY be able to deposit money. She cannot ask for balance information, she cannot add herself to the account, withdraw money, etc. providing the account is with a reputable bank.
  • temp7542355 If you set up a 529 account some have a deposit link just for this purpose. It probably would be worth your time to check out your state's options.
  • Aduiavas Giving out an account number won't compromise the account. Many people have my bank account number, that doesn't mean they can access the money there. They can deposit money into it, but not take it out. I've added my parents on my main account mainly because it's good to have a back up in case I lose my login, but that's because I trust them. My grandparents send me money on my birthday and some other occasions, but they wouldn't be able to take it out.
  • Acrobatic_Jaguar_623 NTA, But.......it's kinda dumb. She can't withdraw money from it only deposit so why are you worried?
  • Itls YoNoHeSido I don't think that you understand how bank accounts work. She can't get ANY information about his account just from the account number and sort code. All she can do is put money in. Why would that be a problem?
  • Deflated_Hypnotist YTA Giving someone the account and routing info to make a deposit doesn't give them access You're just making it harder for her to give your kid money for no reason

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article